Learn in groups: Learn COVID vaccine side effects on Facebook

Narrative and social media

About this project

social media.png

Concept overview

This is a (fictitious) Facebook group, designed for people are vaccinated (fully or first dose) to share their experiences about their side effects and how they feel. This is a purely personal anecdotal sharing community that is not intended to be used as any scientific research, trial or experiment.

Statement of need

People need to understand the side effects of different COVID vaccines from a personal and realistic perspective. A community of practice is needed for people who are already vaccinated and people who have questions about the COVID vaccine so that they can ask for help and exchange thoughts as needed.

Target audience

  • Users who are interested in taking the vaccine but still not sure

  • Users who took the first dose and on their way for the second dose

  • Users who are fully vaccinated and want to share their experiences with others as references

Learning goals and objectives

Goals

Users of the Facebook group would form a trustworthy, supportive, and helpful community of practice of sharing vaccine-related information and help.

Objectives

In this Facebook group, users will be able to

  • List and identify some common and potential uncommon side effects for different vaccines after the first or second dose by reading off other people's experiences

  • Understand some effective treatments for common side effects

  • Describe ways to report serious side effects to corresponding authorities and departments if it happens

  • Get personal experience-based answers from others on the questions they ask for

Design thinking and process

Keep being inspired by the concept of learning on social media, I found myself discovering a new way of learning when I was working on the "Learning in the wild" project last semester for Foundation of Learning Science class. While thinking about me aggressively looking for some advice for vaccine since my second dose is coming in a week, I found myself not really interested in reading news articles or science publications, but rather than listening to my friends and their friends' experiences after getting the vaccine. Researching on social media and reading through my friends' post of their experiences also help me to know more what I should expect and get prepared. In this way, I think a Facebook group of sharing experiences and advice to people in need for vaccines and side effects based on people's personal stories can be interesting and worthy learning topic to be implemented on social media in particular.

Development process

Tools used: Figma

Facebook group name: COVID vaccination thinks and shares

Type of the group: private (need to be approved by the admins to get into the group). This ensures a safe and supportive community that learners need to pass a security protocol by the admins.

Group courtesy: they are created to devote an expectation of how the learning environment of the group should be like:

  • Respect each other’s opinions, privacy, opinions and perspectives.

  • Follow the theme of the group - sharing personal experiences about vaccine experiences and helping each other out.

  • Make sure that learners feel comfortable to talk and share.

What are the topics being promoted:

  • experiences of side effects (or no side effects)

  • what to do with some common side effects

  • what to do if there are serious side effects and where to report to

Using Facebook as a way of learning isn’t a novel idea, while how to best utilize features of the Facebook group function to assist the learning process can be a challenge for learning designers. In this prototype, based on Social Constructivism and Situated Learning theory as the two supportive theories, I will be focusing on using functions such as:

  • Posting and threads/subthreads

  • Creating pollings

  • Ask questions

  • The pined announcement by the group admins

  • Role of group members: members, moderators, and admins

Design rationales

Social constructivism (Lev Vygotsky)

Learning in a social setting is constructing collective knowing than individual knowledge - this is a shared "knowing" as a human product that is made available for everyone in the group.

  • Social interaction as the main medium of knowledge acquisition: Learners learn and share knowledge through rapid social interactions such as replying, asking questions, reacting (with emojis), discussing with each other, etc.

  • Shared goal and knowledge building: A collective knowledge about common vaccine side effects and some meditating treatments are being constructed by the group members based on their personal stories

  • Joint meaning-making process: There is not a role of “instructor” in the group that is responsible for all the "teaching". Learners learn by discussing actively under one or more posts' threads and sub-threads. It's a process that learners of the community are working on building a shared understanding on vaccine side effects. Moderators and admins of the group can be seen as “More Knowledgeable Others” that facilitate and guide the discussion.

Situated theory (Jean Lave)

Situated learning theory in a Facebook group can be seen Learning through social interaction with a focus on situational cognition, in this case, specifically applicable to learners who have a vaccination in their plan against COVID.

  • Community of Practice (CoP): Communities of practice are formed by people who engage in a process of collective learning in a shared domain of human endeavor: in this case, understanding the experiences with the vaccine. Users of the group are either interested in getting vaccinated, or already are vaccinated that they can share personal stories.

  • Participation metaphor: the participation metaphor relates to learning activities considered in context, rather than learning states. Learning described by this metaphor does not consist of the having of knowledge but of learning through doing activities that are ongoing. Anna Sfard likened participation learning to become a member of a certain community - being an active member of the community is an active way of learning in this group.

Social learning (Albert Bandura)

  • The social learning theory of Bandura emphasizes the importance of observing and modeling the behaviors, attitudes, and emotional reactions of others: Individuals are more likely to adopt a modeled behavior if the model is similar to the observer and has admired status and the behavior has functional value. By sharing authentic experiences as the core part of learning content in this group, it's more relatable to individuals than the data from scientific research journals or publications, which can be cold and distant from people.

Prototype

Disclaimer: posts, comments and threads are taken from Facebook group "COVID-19 Vaccine Side Effects" with names and profile pictures replaced.

Facebook group introduction and group rules

Facebook group introduction and group rules

Post 1.png

Pined admin posts that welcome new learners and enourage discussion and shares in the community

Rise a question and ask peers of the community for support and help

Rise a question and ask peers of the community for support and help

Group home page.png
Learners share their personal anecdotes and experiences about vaccine experiences and actively engaged in group discussion as a way of building collective “knowing”.

Learners share their personal anecdotes and experiences about vaccine experiences and actively engaged in group discussion as a way of building collective “knowing”.

Actively participate in the group polling and provide some personal data on the side effects after vaccination shot which can be great references for others in the group.

Actively participate in the group polling and provide some personal data on the side effects after vaccination shot which can be great references for others in the group.

Limitations and future work

There are already numbers of similar Facebook groups either private or public out there, however, sustainability under post-pandemic will be a problem - how to keep the group running and meaningful to people? It is worth thinking if Facebook groups should be designed just for the pandemic, or it can be staying longer and meaningful for the audience.

The role of administrators and moderators should be carefully thought through as well. From a social constructivist perspective, there is not especially a role of “instructors” but “facilitators”: those people can be “More Knowledgeable Others” that facilitate the social interactions and discussions happening in the community. Do the admins need to evaluate the moderators’ expertise on vaccine or COVID-19 as a factor the social learning process can be better moderated and facilitated with guidance and helps? This is an important factor that has to be considered in order to make the group useful and meaningful to individual members to share and construct knowledge together based on each others’ prior knowledge or personal stories.

Reference

Sfard, A. (1998). On Two Metaphors for Learning and the Dangers of Choosing Just One. Educational Researcher, 27(2), 4–13. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189x027002004

Situated Learning (J. Lave). (2018, November 30). InstructionalDesign.Org. http://www.instructionaldesign.org/theories/situated-learning/

Social Development Theory (Lev Vygotsky). (2018, November 30). InstructionalDesign.Org. http://www.instructionaldesign.org/theories/social-development/

Social Learning Theory (Albert Bandura). (2018, November 30). InstructionalDesign.Org. http://www.instructionaldesign.org/theories/social-learning/